KEY IMMIGRATION DECISIONS

A curated review of recent Federal Court decisions with practical implications for Canadian immigration practitioners.

NOVEMBER 6–13, 2026

THIS WEEK AT A GLANCE

This week: citizenship and protected-person PR delays, a threatening note omitted from the claim narrative, and what it takes to challenge an internal flight alternative. Judgments dated November 6–12, 2026.

FEDERAL COURT CASE TO WATCH

TIPS TO CHANGE YOUR PRACTICE

THE IMMIGRATION JUDGES DESK

WON, LOST & WHY IT MATTERS

OUR KEY INSIGHT THIS WEEK

FEDERAL COURT CASE TO WATCH

CASE 01

When citizenship screening outlasts the explanation

Kaba v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1378

The applicant had waited about 37 months for a citizenship decision. The published average when he applied was 10 months. He had completed the required assessments, provided biometrics and repeatedly sought updates.

Justice D’Agostino treated the published estimate as a benchmark and examined what the file showed about this particular delay.

The record showed administrative activity. IRCC identified no specific complexity or outstanding inquiry that explained why security screening remained pending for over three years (paras 19–25).

In applying Benison, the Court considered prejudice as part of the balance of convenience and found no demonstrated disproportionate impact on the administrative process or public safety (paras 26–28).

WHY RCICs SHOULD CARE

Keep the estimate in force at filing, dated responses, proof of compliance and any case-specific explanation for the delay. A chronology gives counsel a way to assess the record against the mandamus test.

OUTCOME

Mandamus Granted. IRCC must decide the citizenship application within 60 days of judgment. No costs were awarded and no question was certified.

Kaba v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1378
Docket T-1486-25

FEDERAL COURT CASE TO WATCH

CASE 02
A late fairness letter and a five-year PR wait

Bisultanov v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1375

A family’s protected-person permanent residence application had been pending about 65 months. IRCC had referred the file for external security screening in August 2022 after receiving the requested employment information.

A procedural fairness letter raised substantive admissibility concerns and showed progress. Justice D’Agostino found that it still left years of screening unexplained. The Court allowed time for IRCC to assess the response and resolve admissibility (paras 23–31).

WHY RCICs SHOULD CARE

Keep the procedural fairness response moving while assembling the earlier processing history. Record when the underlying information reached IRCC and when IRCC first raised the concern.

OUTCOME

Mandamus Granted. IRCC has 90 days from judgment to decide the permanent residence application. No question was certified.

Bisultanov v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1375
Docket IMM-19144-25

TIPS TO CHANGE YOUR PRACTICE

I would make three changes to the file review this week.

  • Build a dated record of submissions, demands for a decision and IRCC replies. Include the applicant’s response times.

  • Before a refugee hearing, check whether new material facts call for an updated Basis of Claim. Retain originals and document how digital evidence was preserved.

  • For a proposed internal flight alternative, gather evidence specific to each location and address both safety and the practical conditions of relocation.

THE PRACTICAL LESSON

Ask a colleague to reconstruct the file from the record alone. Any unexplained gap is worth addressing before a hearing or referral.

THE IMMIGRATION JUDGES DESK

Aguirre Eugarrios v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1388 · Justice D’Agostino dismissed judicial review. The RAD reasonably assessed credibility cumulatively. It had considered disclosure of a threatening note, the explanation for leaving it out of the Basis of Claim, and the account of how potentially corroborating digital evidence was lost (paras 18–24).

PRACTICAL LITIGATION POINT

Review the narrative with the claimant after significant new developments. If evidence is missing or was deleted, document when, why and what remains available. Preserve it securely in a way that accounts for the claimant’s safety.

WON, LOST & WHY IT MATTERS

Sanchez v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1382 · Justice Joyal dismissed judicial review. The RAD accepted the cartels’ ability to find the claimant, then assessed their motivation to pursue him in the proposed cities. The record supported the RAD’s findings about the geographic scope of the threats, the claimant’s profile and the circumstances of relocation (paras 14–37).

Kaba and Bisultanov obtained orders requiring decisions within set periods. In Sanchez and Aguirre Eugarrios, the RAD decisions stood.

WHAT I WOULD TAKE INTO THE NEXT FILE

For an internal flight alternative, I would identify what shows continuing interest in this particular claimant and connect it to each proposed city. I would also raise any distinct returnee-risk argument before the RAD so it can address it.

Sanchez v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1382
Docket IMM-13363-24

OUR KEY INSIGHT THIS WEEK

A brief reflection by Hooshang Lotfi, MBA, CPA, RCIC-IRB, Managing Partner, LM Law & CPA LLP

Colleagues, when I review a stalled application, I ask someone to read the chronology without the client’s explanation. Can they tell what IRCC was waiting for, when the client responded and which period remains unexplained? If they can’t, I go back to the dated requests, responses and proof of delivery.

In Kaba, the Court had a published processing estimate for context and examined whether IRCC explained the delay on that file. In Bisultanov, a later procedural fairness letter showed progress but did not account for the years that had already passed. I would keep two tasks moving at once: answer the fairness letter by its deadline and preserve the earlier history for counsel. The Court ordered decisions within 60 and 90 days in those files. Those were deadlines set by the judgments, not processing standards.

I apply the same discipline to refugee files. In Aguirre Eugarrios, disclosure of a threatening note did not resolve its omission from the Basis of Claim or the credibility concerns. I would review significant new facts with the claimant, consider whether the narrative needs updating, and document when and how the evidence was disclosed.

In Sanchez, the ability to locate the claimant and the motivation to pursue him were separate questions. For each proposed internal flight alternative, I would write down what shows continued interest in this claimant and what makes relocation realistic or difficult in that particular place. Raise material issues before the RAD so it has a chance to address them.

OUR TAKEAWAY THIS WEEK

Before filing or referring a case, write a one-page note. Identify the question that could decide the matter, point to the strongest dated evidence, and name the gap someone still needs to close. That gives the next person a file they can act on.

Hooshang Lotfi’s handwritten signature

Hooshang Lotfi, MBA, CPA, RCIC-IRB
Managing Partner for LM Law & CPA LLP

Have a Federal Court matter or a complex refusal?

If you are an RCIC dealing with a refusal, prolonged processing delay, complex admissibility issue, or a matter that may require judicial review, our team is available to discuss the file with you.

Keep Reading